Authorguy's Blog

Monsters are people too.

Posted on: December 9, 2010


Once upon a time I was a  graduate student in philosophy. (Please contain your shock.)  There is a great deal to be said for and with philosophy, and I think fantasy as a genre is a great way to say and think it.  One key area in which these two subjects overlap is that of monsters.

To most people, I suppose, a monster is any creature that poses a threat to a major character (i.e., ourselves) and usually represents an evil power, to boot.  I took a class in school on the subject of Aesthetics, and I did my term paper on the subject of horror and monsters, based on a book that had recently come out called The Philosophy of Horror, or Paradoxes of the Heart, by Noel Carroll. His claim was that monsters instill in us a feeling of horror because they transcend boundaries that we use to categorize the world around us. They break our neat little pigeonholes, confuse our categories, leave us ignorant and bereft even of words to think of them with, thus simultaneously terrorizing us and filling us with disgust, the two components of horror. (My apologies to Mr. Carroll if I’ve misstated his position, even in brief. It’s been a while since I read the book.)

While I don’t argue with his position regarding fear, I did find his arguments regarding disgust to be less than compelling. I don’t believe that our categories are so hard and fast as all that. I don’t believe we learn about the world so much as we experience parts of it and make up stories to explain what we just experienced. These stories get condensed into words. ‘Learning’ is when we are given a sound by someone else, assume it to be a word like the ones we already know, and then try to create a story that will give it the meaning it seeems to have based on how the other guy used it.

So we don’t get words like ‘spider’ as a given thing, we invent it. So it’s perfectly feasible for us to revise that word to include other concepts like ‘giant’. A giant spider, however terrifying it might be, is not an object of revulsion per se. Giant gila monsters even less so.

There is only one category which is in a sense ‘given’ to us, ourselves.  My idea of a man is based on my experience of myself. You are considered a man by me to the extent that my experience of you is like my experience of me. (In fact, my idea of everything is based on how closely it resembles my idea of me, but that’s a little deep for this post so I’ll just leave it lie.)

It follows then that the only real monsters are humans. Undead? Yes. Mutants? Possibly. Zombies? Sure. Not that monsters have to be supernatural, there are lots of evildoers in the real world that qualify, but in fantasy we get to make the more abstract forms of wrongness real. The Incredible Shrinking Man was not evil, exactly, what filled us with horror was that he’d become prey, first to the cat, then to the spider, shich had become giant only because he’d become small. The true monsters of LOTR are Saruman, Sauron, the Nazgul, people who knew better and corrupted themselves, not the balrog, not even the orcs and trolls.

I make this point in A Warrior Made as follows:

“You mean its name?” replied Janosec.  He looked over to his uncle in confusion.  “Why would a monster like that need a name?”

Tarkas shook his head negatively.  “She means its kind, nephew,” he clarified, and projected his next comment forward, “It was called a grunt.”

She snorted.  “Appropriate.” 

Tarkas continued, for Janosec’s benefit now, “Nor was it a monster.  Monstrous, perhaps, but all of the true monsters I’ve had to deal with had names.”

She snorted, dismissing the point.  “Monster or monstrosity, I wager the distinction never stayed your sword.”

“You have already lost,” the Hero said quietly…

Tarkas kills monsters simply because they exist, but not monstrosities. Not unless they become a threat.

What’s your take?

Advertisements

2 Responses to "Monsters are people too."

We have lots of reasons for monsters and lots of explanations for monsters, so it depends on the viewpoint of the individual and purpose for declaring something a monster. Long ago someone might have considered “Frankenstein’s monster” a monster, but a more thorough reading of the book would indicate that the real monster was Frankenstein himself. Dracula is/was considered a monster, but a thorough understanding of him maybe makes him less so.

The real question again is ‘why do we need monsters’? The answer in the case of the popularity of the zombie apocalypse genre is often that we feel the need to revert back to simpler times and a simpler life while also imagining ourselves as one of the few strong enough and smart enough to survive. Thus these monsters makes us feel good about ourselves in a way.

But what do Mike Myers from “Friday the 13th” and Freddie Kruger do for us? Is it just good to be reminded that we are alive like tragedies remind us to be thankful?

Horror today is different than horror from long ago. Poe and Lovecraft are ancient masters, but do they really thrill us anymore or do we just have to appreciate them for what they were and how expertly they wove a tale that used to be “horrifying”?

Like

I’ve always regarded the Freddy Krueger style slasher flicks as exercises in portraying graphic and violent death via special effects, rather than real movies.
The zombie apocalypse can also be a symptom of either dumbing down (undead corpses are pretty obviously grotesque) or simply a last bastion, in a world where vampires and werewolves are sex symbols.

Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Unbinding the Stone

A Warrior Made

A Warrior Made

Click here to BUY NOW!

St. Martin’s Moon

St. Martin's Moon

Click cover to Buy Now!

Ghostkiller

Chasing His Own Tale

Click Here to Buy Now!

Struck By Inspiration

Struck By Inspiration

Click here to Buy Now!

Steampunk Santa

Click here to Buy Now!

Bite Deep

Christmas among the vampires!

Click Here to BUY NOW!

Click here to buy NOW!

Cyber-pirates. Sort of.

Click here to BUY NOW!

Off the Map

Reality TV...without the Reality!

Author Guy’s Tweets

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 625 other followers

What has gone before

Blog Stats

  • 8,625 hits
%d bloggers like this: